Red Dwarf Book Reviews

An Unwieldy Wrapup

A huge thanks to folks who checked out my guestbook! I read every comment, and I will endeavour to reply to them in due time (I forgot the password and have been procrastinating on resetting it)... Like a certain communications officer, I would send my thoughts out into the void even if nobody read them, but it means a lot to me when people share their thoughts and what they've been reading. In other exciting news, I've been working on proper Home/About pages, plus adding a contact page - I took a computer science course once wayyy back in high school and forgot nearly everything, but I've been learning HTML through a course the library offers, so that's been fun.

The temperatures here have dropped dramatically, and we're set to see our first snow of the season soon. In anticipation for that, I want to ask - what are some books people recommend as we settle into the winter? As for myself, I have two. First up is Terry Pratchett's Going Postal. I know folks are incredulous when they hear that you don't need to (and really shouldn't!) start with the first Discworld books, but Going Postal is the 33rd instalment and I couldn't have asked for a better introduction to the world. In it, you follow Moist von Lipwig, a conman who is given a choice - well, given is a generous use of the word - between execution and restoring Ankh-Morpork's postal service to its former glory. If you've ever watched Better Call Saul, imagine Moist as Saul Goodman, a fast-talking sleazebag who you can't help be endeared to as the story goes along. Without going too much into spoilers, the story feels all the more relevant today, and I associate it with the holidays because it reminds me a bit of watching Bah-Humduck annually around December. My other recommendation would be the second book in Rick Yancey's The Monstrumologist series (I know, I know, I have a condition called I must plug these books whenever possible. It is incurable). I love the descriptions of the snow and desolation in this one, and I am always thinking about what is possibly Warthrop and Will Henry's greatest fight.

Since I'm still recuperating, this entry is a little unwieldy wrapup of some titles I've read from September to now. As usual, if you want to see everything I've been reading, you can head on over to my Storygraph @readdwarreviews.

Medalist volumes 10 and 11 by TSURUMAIKADA - I know I have sung Medalist's praises before, and I'll sing them again! I cannot go into much detail about the plot without spoilers, but volume 10 handled raw discussions of growing pains, puberty, and the toxic culture that leads to body dysmorphia for the young girls enmeshed in the sport. I would recommend Medalist to anyone, but I would especially recommend it to younger girls. Something I really appreciate about Medalist in general is how children's autonomy is respected. The adults in Inori's life take great care to talk and listen to her - whenever a choice regarding her future comes up, or she hits a roadblock, they don't decide things for her. They give her the information and tools so that she can grasp her future with her own two hands. We see that Inori is fortunate compared to what some of her peers have gone through, and I really like how Tsukasa advocates for her to have a career that doesn't come at the cost of her health and wellbeing.

Colette Decides to Die omnibus Volume 6 by Alto Yukimura - I can't recall if I've ever mentioned this series before, but this is a cute shojo that gives me all the giddiness I would feel reading shojo manga as a middle/highschooler. It's a Greek mythology retelling and back when I first decided to check it out, I was wary, because haven't we had enough Hades and Persephone retellings? I will take an exception to Colette :> The series kicks off with Colette, an overworked apothecary in a village that has no others. In a fit of despair, she decides to commit suicide. However, instead of dying, she ends up in the Underworld, and comes to be the personal physician for Hades. Volume 6 has Colette and Hades finally confessing their feelings to each other - I don't think the burn was slow enough, but it wasn't the romantic developments that drew me in. We see Colette visit a village that has a single man caring for the villagers. Much like Colette, he is overworked, but there's an key difference between Colette's village and this one - here, women are strongly discouraged from pursuing medicine. Were it not for the patriarchal traditions, there would be more healers, and we get a girl named Sasara who is mesmerized by watching Colette work. Inspired by her, she decides to help, but faces opposition to her work - some of it from her own family. Ultimately she does decide to study to become an apothecary and I found her storyline to be very grounded. Another storyline this volume that I was quite fond of was that of Dionysus and Hermes. Similarly to the Greek myths, Dionysus was frequently the target of Hera's wrath, and it's Hermes who frequently keeps an eye out for him despite claiming to be sick of the guy. Really moved by seeing their relationship from Hermes perspective!

Bodies of Art, Bodies of Labour by Kate Beaton - This is a publication of Beaton's lecture at the Centre for Literatures in Canada series. I was going to watch the lecture itself, but this slim volume was all I had on hand during a particularly long commute one day so I ended up reading most of it then. Beaton talks about class disparities in who gets published, and I hadn't thought a great deal about it before. So often you get studies that break down publishing by race, gender, sexuality, among other categories, but there isn't as much reporting on class - at least not in Canada. Beaton goes on to talk about her experiences growing up in Cape Breton, and how tourists flocked to the area expecting her home to be this idyllic place for them to gawk at the salt of the earth, maybe even roleplay for a couple of weeks before returning to their lives in the city. Something I appreciated was her saying that the knowledge deficit goes both ways - it is not just the working class that does not know about upper class rituals, they have much to learn too. She did mention quite a few authors and texts that I will certainly be checking out, and I do think it'll be worth watching the lecture at a later date, if only to see the composition of the audience. Who can afford to attend these lectures? Whose donations uphold the CLC? Where do the audience members laugh, and where are there uncomfortable silences? Kate Beaton was pretty popular around 2012 or so for her comics on history and literature. I can guarantee that even if you do not know her name, you have seen at least one of her comics before. They're hilarious, I got a copy of her first comic collection as a graduation gift a few years ago, but I also want to take a moment to recommend her graphic memoir, Ducks: Two Years in the Oil Sands. It is a chunky book and one of my favourite memoirs out there.

The Other A in LGBTQIA+ by AUREA - Much to my disappointment, I actually did not finish this one... I've been looking for fiction and nonfiction about aromanticism, and this was one recommendation that popped up. In some ways it felt very basic - discussing how aromanticism could intersect with other identities, that just felt incredibly common sense to me - and needlessly complicated in others - there were a couple of portions that listed pages of microlabels and their definitions. I'm certain this text will be of help to someone, but it felt a tad too dry for my liking. The one thing I did like were the portions where people spoke of their experiences. I would greatly appreciate any recommendations for any media about aromanticism that looks at it less from an introductory aspect to more in-depth stuff like how society is structured in a way that tangibly harms anyone who falls outside the bounds of strict heteronormative and amatonormative expectations.

Daemons of the Shadow Realm volumes 9 and 10 by Hiromu Arakawa - One thing about Arakawa is that she knows how to make her characters play 4d chess. Anyone can have any number of motivations at any given point in time and who on earth knows where their loyalties are. There's some lore in volume 10 that left me slackjawed. EDIT: As of November 12, I have just finished volume 11 and I NEED TO KNOW WHAT HAPPENS NEXT ASAP! When this series hits, it really hits, and my pulse was racing while I ripped through pages.

Ichi the Witch volumes 3 and 4 - So I was on the fence about this series when I first started because the premise rubbed me the wrong way - it's a universe where only women can become witches until one day, our main character becomes a witch, and a very powerful one at that. I've a sneaking suspicion that the author wanted to write a story about women, but had to sneak Ichi in there as a Trojan horse to tell the story she really wanted to. It's not doing anything particularly groundbreaking so far (though it's a battle shonen, you'd be hard-pressed to break new ground in the genre), but I am having a fun time and the character designs and worldbuilding are interesting. The real draw of the series for me so far is Ichi's mentor, Desscaras. We see a hint of her past in volume 3, and I so desperately need to know more about her. There's something she does in the third volume that solidified her and Ichi as another mentor-pupil dynamic to add to my repertoire.

How We Get Free: Black Feminism and the Combahee River Collective, edited by Keeanga Yamahtta Taylor - This is an excellent introduction to Black feminism, and more specifically, the lives and work of women involved in The Combahee River Collective. The book opens with the CRC Statement, which I highly recommend everyone read. In the statement, the authors discuss how isolation within both the women's movement and the Civil Rights movement led them to creating the collective, and they argued that because they were treated as secondary in both circles, it was up to them to work for their liberation. What really stood out to me was the use of identity politics as outlined in their statement. In today's political climate the term has been dragged through the mud and so thoroughly mangled beyond its original meaning, and I do think it's a term people should really learn about before using it in a derogatory manner. "Our politics evolve from a healthy love for ourselves, our sisters and our community which allows us to continue our struggle and work. The focusing on our own oppression is embodied in the concept of identity politics. We believe that the most profound and potentially radical politics come directly out of our own identity, as opposed to working to end somebody else's oppression. In the case of Black women, this is a particularly repugnant, dangerous, threatening, and therefore revolutionary concept because it is obvious from looking at all the political movements that have preceded us that anyone is more worthy of liberation than ourselves. We reject pedestals, queenhood, and walking ten paces behind. To be recognized as human, levelly human, is enough". The rest of the book follows Taylor's interviews with several women involved in the founding of the CRC, and I found the interviews to be both depressing and encouraging. I am not American, but I have seen the gains made by the US during the midterms and saw that Black women played an integral part in turning the tide in large part because their identities form their politics. When you look at exit polls that showcase the breakdown of results by demographics, Black women tend to vote for Democrats more so than any other demographic. Reading about the political climate that the founders lived through versus the political climate today, there have been some enormous strides. At the same time, these victories are not etched in stone, and we must all be vigilant against the creep of fascism worldwide. As I said before, this book is a great introduction to Black feminism, and the founders frequently reference Black feminist artists, texts, magazines, and more - avenues for further reading and research. As someone who used to work for a feminist collective, there's nothing more fascinating than seeing what women in the past were writing about, and I love looking to the past to see what we can learn from their struggles and successes.

Catching Fire by Suzanne Collins - I reread The Hunger Games over the summer, and decided to reread CF in anticipation for the Sunrise on the Reaping movie. This was always my favourite of the trilogy, and the reread was no exception. The actual Quarter Quell was much shorter than I remembered it being, but I think the brewing rebellion was one of the things that always compelled me more so than any flashy stuff going on in the arena. A new facet always seems to jump out to me with every reread, and this time it was the visceral horror of Katniss's relationship with Peeta. The fake romance that started as a survival strategy in the 74th Games hung around her like a noose after she got out, strangling any chances at a life on her own terms. Katniss and Peeta may have been relatively "fortunate" especially when you compare what the Capitol took from them compared to some of the other tributes like Finnick and Johanna (Haymitch fought folks in the first book to stop them from modifying Katniss's breasts after she won), but there's something so stomach churning of being shackled to a person, forced to act like a loving couple to avoid death. "Of course, I could do a lot worse than Peeta. That isn't really the point though, is it? One of the few freedoms we have in District 12 is the right to marry who we want or not marry at all. And now even that has been taken away from me". Love as a prison is such a delicious concept, and I'm curious how reading the books through this lens will impact my reread of Mockingjay.

One and Only by Maurene Goo - I said I'd stop reading contemporary romances because I rarely have a fun time with them, but I occasionally like to inflict upon myself a unique form of torture called, checking the 7 day loan collection on Libby and signing out an audiobook I know I probably won't enjoy. Reader, this was - and I hope it remains - my worst read of the year. I haven't decided whether I want to write an in-depth review of what I hated about it, especially because that would mean revisiting the book to make my case. A veritable nightmare of a book for an aromantic, and I find it depressing that it's a contender in the opening round of the Goodreads Choice Awards (though those awards aren't worth anything in my eyes, so even if it won it would not be an indicator of quality).

Skip and Loafer by Misaki Takamatsu volume 12 - I read this on October 30th and it was pretty timely because this volume covers the end of the trip arc and gets into the school festival arc. In a previous volume, Shima was cast as Frankenstein's monster for a play, much to the dismay of someone who felt that Shima had it all and could not possibly relate to the monster. Seeing how Shima's past as a child actor alienated him from his peers and his family made my heart hurt, and I really do hope good things come to him soon. Perhaps this is a sign for me to finally read Frankenstein...

Trash! A Garbageman's Story by Simon Paré-Poupart - I listened to this on audio and it was far too short for my liking. The first part of the book focuses on the author's upbringing and his introduction to working as a garbageman in Quebec. He talks about his fellow garbagemen and the conditions that brought them into the industry. He does not claim for this to be a universal analysis, but he writes that many of his colleagues came from working class families and many dealt with family histories of addiction before turning to addiction themselves. He highlights how conditions like these are ripe for worker exploitation, and talks about some predatory practices used to keep men behind the truck. Unlike many of his colleagues, Paré-Poupart is sober and a formally educated man, and he waxes philosophical at many points, bringing together both a personal history and a larger history of trash. Unfortunately, many of his tangents feel too brief. For instance, he touches upon unionizing, the move toward privatization, overconsumption, the outsourcing of trash to countries outside of the imperial core and so much more. In listening to this I first learned about the Memphis sanitation strike, which followed the deaths of two Black workers who due to Jim Crow laws, were forced to shelter in their compactor during a storm and later killed when it accidentally activated. I learned that Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. marched with the workers and delivered his final speech there before he was assassinated the following day. The audiobook narrator had a great boisterous energy that matched the text's original tone, and I easily would have listened to several more hours if it meant that Paré-Poupart could develop and connect the ideas he wrote about more thoroughly.

A Witch's Life in Mongol volume 1 by Tomato Soup - Though I'd read the first volume for this in 2025, I decided to reread it since I've been watching the anime. This follows the story of Sitara, a real woman who was involved in the downfall of the Mongol Empire. My library only has the first volume, but what a gorgeous volume it is - I think I like the anime a little better because it has an anime original introduction that really took my breath away - it was the first time I'd ever heard the Athaan recited in a show in a context that didn't frame it as scary. Depending on how long the series runs, I would love to own the manga, or at the very least, this first volume.

The Art Thief by Michael Finkel - Another audiobook on the books, and I've very conflicting feelings about this one. It's a nonfiction about Stéphane Breitwieser, a Frenchman who robbed nearly 200 objects from museums and galleries across Europe between 1995 - 2001. I realize that pop nonfiction like this is meant to be salacious, but I couldn't help but feel all too keenly some of the issues that made Breitwieser's heists so easy. Lack of funding - especially for smaller museums which he stole from frequently - has only worsened, and many museum thefts aren't as flashy as the author would have you believe. Back in 2024, The Guardian published a piece on a museum employee who had been selling pieces from storage. Museums are shockingly easy to steal from, and if an institution as large as the British Museum faces issues as these, you can only imagine what smaller museums face with far fewer resources. I also disliked the author's admiration of Breitwieser, taking him at his word when he claimed his motives for theft to be pure and somehow above the "common" criminal. At the end of the book, the author discloses that he had partaken in extensive talks with the thief, and even witnessed him partake in criminal activity a couple of times. I think this note - or some sort of indication on the author's primary source should have been disclosed at the start of the book, not at the very end. I find myself nowhere near as taken in by Breitwieser's supposed charisma, I just think that he was able to get away with what he did in part due to poor funding, security, and the fact that he was white. Even overlooking the author's admiration of his subject, this isn't a particularly impressive work on a technical level. At some point, the descriptions of Breitwieser's thefts blur together, and there are several phrases that I heard repeatedly. If you want a more compellingly crafted narrative nonfiction about an art heist, I highly recommend Nicholas Day's The Mona Lisa Vanishes. It's written for a younger audience, but readers of any age will delight in a far more well-crafted story. It's also got gorgeous illustrations by Brett Helquist throughout - he's the artist who also illustrated Lemony Snicket's A Series of Unfortunate Events.

The Hound of the Baskervilles by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle - Though I read this earlier than some of the other titles in this wrapup, I wanted to save the best for last! If you've read my previous entries or have had the (mis)fortune (depending on who you talk to) of talking to me online or in real life in the past couple of months, you will know that back in February I embarked upon a journey to work my way through every single Sherlock Holmes story, and have fallen down what is promising to be a never ending rabbit hole. Long before I set out on this road I knew I wanted to read HOUN (it delights me to no end the short titles that exist for every story!), and October was the perfect time to read it. This is hands down my favourite Sherlock story I've read so far, and I suspect it will stay that way throughout my journey. In previous entries I've spoken about how wrong I'd been about Holmes, how poorly I'd judged him due to popular interpretations, but after reading HOUN I must issue an apology to John Watson too - I was not familiar with your game, sir! The atmosphere in this was amazing, I could get lost in the descriptions of the moor and not find my way out. There was a time I worried that the story would not live up to my expectations, but I can happily say it exceeded them. I definitely want to read this annually - I just so had the good fortune to be reading parts of it the same time as Watson's letters to Holmes! Next up, The Return of Sherlock Holmes!

Currently reading: